The Nolitan

Also shout out to the amazing staff ~ I felt some clothing hanging in the closet & didn’t realize it until the following day….they held my items & I was able to have them picked up & delivered to me. You will not be disappointed with this hotel

Great location, but the condition of the room and property was very disappointing. For example, there was something sticky on the bathroom walls, the hangers in the closet were broken, and there were clumps of hair on our towles, as well as on the bathroom floor. I also had some safety concerns, as when we returned to the hotel lobby late in the evening there was no staff that appeared to be monitoring the lobby and there was what looked to be a homeless man sleeping in the lobby.

Very good

Good

Good

rooms are lovely - great location and views room was dusty throughout, light broke in the toilet and took 2 days to fix, air-conditioning broken, restaurant is shut and has been for years and the rooftop also isnt open and now after asking me to email with problems I have and received no reply after 7 days

Loved this hidden gem with excellent service:)

Staff was SO kind I loved them! Very attentive, kind, helpful. Dropped everything to help me. Answered all my questions - location is amazing! Everything around you. I loved the room & fun bathtub to unwind and relax after a long day! Will be seeing them again soon! Thank you so much for your hospitality!

Very good

Absolutely loved this hotel! We had a top floor room with balcony that looked over the whole skyline. Rooms aren’t fancy but are clean and comfortable. Staff is excellent and they have a deal with a gym down the block which was great. Location is 1000/10 It’s a bit of a loud location but normal NYC street noise - also shower water pressure could be a bit better.

Very good

Decent stay and location. Nothing specifically negative, just that my expectations were higher for a boutique property and Nolitan was a "solid" but nothing particularly stood out. The room could have been a bit larger and the balcony (which we paid extra for) was not very functional or inviting.

Great location, decent room size (for NYC). A bit loud even with closed windows. very long check-in... considering you arrive around midnight, are the only person to check-in, and have room already pre-paid it was disappointing.

Superb

This place is and A+ in my opinion. Everyone at the front desk was super helpful and friendly. The rooms were clean, spacious and quiet for the most part. The neighborhood is absolutely incredible, walkable, and safe. Would 100% recommend.

This is the 3rd time I have stayed here and would return again. Rooms are small but clean. AC works great. The balcony rooms are my favorite, even though the traffic noise can be a lot. I really appreciated the coffee in the lobby every morning! Housekeeping very reliable. Front desk staff friendly. Great location. I give it 5 stars!

Exceptional

If you're looking for a comfortable, well-located NYC stay without the sky-high price tag, this is an excellent choice. The room was noticeably larger than most New York hotel rooms, with a comfortable mattress, great temperature control, and the rare bonus of a balcony door that opens for fresh air. The balcony itself offers that quintessential New York view and energy—city rooftops, movement, and atmosphere that make you feel immersed in the city from the moment you wake up. What truly sets this hotel apart is the location. You're steps from some of the best shopping in the city, incredible fitness studios, and favorites like Butcher's Daughter for breakfast. Everything you want to experience is right outside your door. Book this hotel for its unbeatable location, clean and comfortable rooms, authentic NYC vibe, and value—it's one of the more affordable ways to stay in the heart of it all without sacrificing comfort. A few things to be aware of before booking: the balcony rooms face a busy street, and on Saturday night the noise was significant enough that I barely slept. From Sunday through Thursday it was noticeably quieter, but I still relied on earplugs each night. If you're a light sleeper, I'd recommend requesting a room away from the street or packing earplugs. The room itself was very clean, but many of the finishes and furnishings are showing their age. While everything was well maintained, the wear from years of guest use can make parts of the room appear less fresh at first glance. I was also disappointed to find that the rooftop deck and restaurant were closed during my stay. One of the reasons I booked this property was to use the rooftop space, and there was no mention of the closure on the Booking.com listing prior to arrival. A notice on the listing would have helped manage expectations. Overall, the location and value are excellent, but it's worth knowing about the street noise and checking whether all amenities are open before booking.

Superb

Good